I'm surprised that Edwards was cut midseason; however, he deserves it. He was the reincarnation of JP Losman. I expect the Bills to continue to flip-flop QBs.
Situation: Fragile
Dolphins:
I was expecting Pennington to take over and win another comeback player of the year award; however, Chad Henne is looking like a reliable starter.
Situation: Solid, but not great.
Patriots:
Tom Brady
Situation: Great, if not super.
Jets:
After a horrid week 1, Sanchez is looking like the best Jets QB since Namath; however, that isn't too difficult to do.
Situation: Solid.
Ravens:
Flacco finally emerged in week 3. Bulger is always an option.
Situation: Solid-esque.
Bengals:
Carson Palmer. He really needs some reliable competition.
Situation: Solid by default.
Browns:
Delhomme was not the pre-season Delhomme and then he got hurt. Seneca Wallace has been the best Browns QB since Jeff Garcia(?). Oh, wait Derek Anderson once was good wasn't he?
Situation: Undecided for the time being.
Steelers:
What a luxury. Roethlisberger isn't available. Dennis Dixon and Charlie Batch are winning. Leftwich could probably win with this team.
Situation: Solid with any of the 4 QBs.
Texans:
Schaub
Situation: Great, if not super.
Colts:
P Manning... 9 tds 0 ints
Situation: Super
Jaguars:
Garrard. With no competition, as McCown is out for the year.
Situation: Solid by default.
Titans:
Vince Young and Kerry Collins may continue to dance all year long. They should stick with Young all year. If he isn't reliable then they should trade him.
Situation: Slightly below solid.
Broncos:
Orton.
Situation: Solid.
Chiefs:
Cassel. Although, he needs competition.
Situation: Solid, sadly.
Raiders:
I was wrong about Campbell and Gradkowski.
Situation: Fragile.
Chargers:
Rivers
Situation: Great, if not super.
Cowboys:
Romo, but needs OL help to take advantage of his skills.
Situation: Great.
Giants:
E Manning
Situation: Just below great. He's playing below his capacity.
Eagles:
Vick. With Kolb waiting.
Situation: Slightly below solid, only because Andy Reid will wait for the first horrid game to bring Kolb back in.
Redskins:
McNabb
Situation: Solid to great
Bears:
Cutler.
Situation: I believe. Solid, if not great.
Packers:
Rodgers, who is not the new Steve Young as I predicted...at least not yet.
Situation: Solid, if not great.
Vikings:
Favre is one or two more bad games from losing his spot to Jackson or the rookie Webb.
Situation: Not great, not even solid.
Lions:
Stafford is hurt. Shaun Hill is boring.
Situation: Slightly below solid until Stafford returns.
Falcons:
Ryan
Situation: Solid, to great.
Panthers:
Clausen, with the possibility of a Moore return. Both are awful.
Situation: Fragile.
Saints:
Brees..over 75% completion.
Situation: Super
Buccaneers:
Freeman with Josh Johnson eager to start, at least somewhere.
Situation: Solid
Cardinals:
Anderson will lose out to undrafted Rookie (and nephew of Danny White from the 80's Cowboys) Max Hall
Situation: Fragile
Rams:
Bradford.
Situation: Solid, yes, with a rookie. Will be best rookie QB since Roethlisberger.
49ers:
Alex Smith will be benched at some point and out of SF
Situation: Slightly above Fragile
Seahawks:
Hasselback.
Situation: Solid